본문바로가기
함께 풀고 싶은 문제
나도 수학쌤 문장제 문제를 변형해 문제를 내는 곳입니다.
[문장제 문제&개념응용] 1+1=1?
백곰 2021.05.10 17:45 조회 455

유튜버 로지컬의 1+1=1을 증명하는 영상을 보고이 영상이 틀렸음을 증명하여보자.

(힌트 : 수2에서 배운 극한을 사용하여 주어진 과정을 무한히 반복하였을 때의 길이를 계산하자.)

이 문제 어떠셨나요?

글쎄요

0

어려워요

0

  •  
    해결
    시그마가싫어요 Lv.9 2021.05.10 23:43 비밀댓글
    비밀 댓글이 등록 되었습니다.
    댓글 작성하기 댓글수0
  •  
    해결
    PF_ Lv.8 2021.05.11 01:11 비밀댓글
    비밀 댓글이 등록 되었습니다.
    댓글 작성하기 댓글수0
  •  
    수학싫은데좋아요 Lv.5 2021.05.12 01:23 비밀댓글
    비밀 댓글이 등록 되었습니다.
    댓글 작성하기 댓글수1
  •  
    백곰 Lv.2 2021.05.12 18:03

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: is_dir(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 201

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 201
    Function: is_dir

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: mkdir(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 202

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 202
    Function: mkdir

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_exists(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex/f7a072d257ff6a0650968a4957c34809.gif) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 212

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 212
    Function: file_exists

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_get_contents(http://latex.codecogs.com/gif.latex?L%28x%29%20%3D%20%5Cfrac%7B2%5Ex%7D%7B2%5E%7Bx-1%7D%7D): Failed to open stream: No route to host

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 213

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 213
    Function: file_get_contents

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_put_contents(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex/f7a072d257ff6a0650968a4957c34809.gif) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 213

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 213
    Function: file_put_contents

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_put_contents(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex/f7a072d257ff6a0650968a4957c34809.gif): Failed to open stream: Operation not permitted

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 213

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 213
    Function: file_put_contents

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: is_dir(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 201

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 201
    Function: is_dir

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: mkdir(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 202

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 202
    Function: mkdir

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_exists(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex/ffd5e890ead190e1c57bfdf752a63994.gif) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 212

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 212
    Function: file_exists

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_get_contents(http://latex.codecogs.com/gif.latex?%5Clim_%7Bx%5Crightarrow%20%5Cinfty%20%7D%5Cfrac%7B2%5E%7Bx%7D%7D%7B2%5E%7Bx-1%7D%7D%20%3D%202): Failed to open stream: No route to host

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 213

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 213
    Function: file_get_contents

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_put_contents(): open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex/ffd5e890ead190e1c57bfdf752a63994.gif) is not within the allowed path(s): (/volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr:/volume1/web:/tmp:/var/tmp:/var/services/tmp:/var/services/web:/volume1/@tmp)

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 213

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 213
    Function: file_put_contents

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    A PHP Error was encountered

    Severity: Warning

    Message: file_put_contents(/DATA/upload/polymath/latex/ffd5e890ead190e1c57bfdf752a63994.gif): Failed to open stream: Operation not permitted

    Filename: libraries/Common.php

    Line Number: 213

    Backtrace:

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 213
    Function: file_put_contents

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/libraries/Common.php
    Line: 236
    Function: getLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view_comment_list.php
    Line: 90
    Function: parseLatexImg

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/views/ver3/inc/view.php
    Line: 343
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/application/controllers/ver3/Contents.php
    Line: 558
    Function: view

    File: /volume1/web/PhpstormProjects/www_polymath_co_kr/index.php
    Line: 315
    Function: require_once

    많은 분들이 풀이를 적어주셨군요! (성은이 망극하옵니다(?) 저언하아)

    일단 제가 푼 풀이를 알려드릴게여

     

    처음 길이를 L(1), 두번째 길이를 L(2), ....라 하면 L(x) = \frac{2^x}{2^{x-1}},

    이때 이를 무한번 반복하였을 때의 길이는 \lim_{x\rightarrow \infty }\frac{2^{x}}{2^{x-1}} = 2이므로 1+1=2다.

     

    다들 정말 잘 푸셨네여 ㄷㄷㄷ... 이게 너튜브에 있었다니;; 내가 먼저 올렸어야 했는데

    댓글 작성하기 좋아요0 댓글수2
    •  
      PF_ Lv.8 2021.05.15 00:41

      근데 왜 정답확인을 안해주시냐고요

      @백곰

      좋아요0
    •  
      시그마가싫어요 Lv.9 2021.06.11 08:54

      전 그냥 나무위키...

      좋아요0
  •  
    루돈 Lv.5 2021.07.11 20:21 비밀댓글
    확인요청중
    비밀 댓글이 등록 되었습니다.
    댓글 작성하기 댓글수0
  •  
    역시나야 Lv.1 2022.01.29 08:43

    무한반복해도 하나의 선이 안될걷같은ㄷ....

    댓글 작성하기 좋아요0 댓글수0
  • 폴리매스 문제는 과학기술진흥기금 및 복권기금의 재원으로 운영되고, 과학기술정보통신부와 한국과학창의재단의 지원을 받아 수행된 성과물로 우리나라의 과학기술 발전과 사회적 가치 증진에 기여하고 있습니다.

  • ☎문의 02-6749-3911